Skip to Content

Why the State Is Leaving Small-Loan Borrowers Unprotected

Bulgaria's new consumer credit law lifts the APR cap for the smallest loans and replaces it with a "20% for one month" rule. Simple arithmetic shows who pays for that choice
14 November 2026 by
Why the State Is Leaving Small-Loan Borrowers Unprotected
Georgi Penev

Why the State Is Leaving Small-Loan Borrowers Unprotected


The consumer credit law exists for one reason: the borrower cannot assess a loan the way the lender can. So the law has to protect the borrower before the contract is signed, not after.

The new Bulgarian law, which Parliament is about to adopt at second reading, does the opposite for exactly the people who need protection most. For loans up to two or three minimum wages it removes the APR cap and replaces it with a cost limit expressed as a percentage of the principal: up to 20% if the loan is repaid within one month. This article is about that rule, and why it should be removed now, before the law is adopted.

Status as of 14 November 2026: the final text has not yet been voted. Figures below follow the government bill and the published second-reading proposals.

APR exists so that prices can be compared


The annual percentage rate (APR) expresses the cost of any loan over the same period, one year, regardless of its term. That is its whole purpose: a one-month loan and a three-month loan can be compared on equal terms.

Today the APR in Bulgaria may not exceed five times the statutory interest rate, about 52%. That limit applies to every loan, large or small, short or long.

The draft takes small loans out of the APR cap and measures them only by "total cost as a percentage of principal". Without APR, 20% for one month looks cheaper than 30% for three months. It is the other way round.

The numbers anyone can check


An APR of 52% means about 3.55 per 100 per month, or about 1.15 per 100 for ten days. That is the legal price of a one-month loan today.

On €100

Current law (52% APR

Draft (one month)

Cost for 10 days

€1.15

—

Cost for 1 month

€3.55

€20.00

APR

52%

800%


20% for one month is 5.6 times today's legal limit. The claim that the current law already makes short loans expensive is not true. Under the law, a one-month loan costs €3.55 per €100. Where borrowers pay far more, it is because of fees charged around the cap, not because the law allows it.

The best borrower pays the highest price


Compare two borrowers, each taking €100 under the draft rules. One can repay in a month. The other needs three months. In a standard annuity schedule:

One month, cost limit 20%

No.

Principal

Interest

Payment

1

100.00

20.00

120.00


Three months, cost limit 30% in total

No.

Balance

Principal

Interest

Payment

1

100.00

28.97

14.36

43.33

2

71.03

33.13

10.20

43.33

3

37.89

37.89

5.44

43.33

The one-month borrower pays 20% for each month of use. The three-month borrower pays 14.36% per month. The person who can repay fastest, the more solvent borrower with the lower risk, is charged the higher price for every month of credit.

That defeats elementary logic. A lender that assesses a borrower properly should offer the loan that suits the borrower best, and the shortest term with the lowest risk should be the cheapest. On what basis does the law allow the shortest loan to be the most expensive one?

The borderline loan: which loan will the lender choose?


The threshold creates a second problem. Take the proposed threshold of two minimum wages, €1,240.40, and a three-month loan:

Borrower asks

for Regime

Cost for 3 months

€1,300

General cap, 52% APR

about €93

€1,240

Small-loan regime, second-reading proposal*

about €320

€1,240

Small-loan regime, government bill (30%)

€372

*Our linear estimate from the published descriptions of the proposal; to be updated if the final text gives the exact formula.

The borrower who asks for less pays three to four times more. The lender's financial incentive is to offer an amount just below the threshold and the shortest term, not to find the loan that is best for the borrower. In this way the smallest borrowers end up covering the lender's costs, from capital and funding to defaults.

Taking a new loan is not repaying a loan


The draft sets no limit on consecutive short loans. A borrower can take a one-month loan, repay it with a new one-month loan, and repeat every month: 12 loans at 20% means €240 a year in cost on €100, while the €100 itself is never actually repaid.

Taking a new loan to close the old one is not repayment. It only moves the debt forward and adds a new cost each time. A borrower who needs a new loan every month is showing, month after month, that they cannot repay. The Directive allows credit to be granted only where the obligations are likely to be met. A law that leaves this rollover unlimited allows lenders to lead the borrower into over-indebtedness one loan at a time, which is in direct conflict with the Directive.

Repeated short loans to the same borrower should count as a breach of the creditworthiness assessment. Where this is systematic, it should lead to loss of the lender's licence.

The threshold: 7, then 3, then 2 minimum wages


The threshold was not set by analysis. During public consultation the industry asked for seven minimum wages. The government bill set three. The second-reading proposal sets two. No published analysis supports any of these numbers.

The threshold is also tied to the minimum wage, so it grows automatically every year without Parliament voting again. And it creates a cliff: a loan just below the threshold may cost several times more than a loan just above it.

A cost cap may be justified, but only on the basis of a published analysis and clear reasoning, not by moving a number from seven to three to two.

Neither the threshold nor the 20% and 30% rules come from the Directive


The Directive requires Member States to prevent excessively high borrowing costs. It does not require a small-loan exception, a minimum-wage threshold, or a 20% one-month tier. The draft published for consultation in December 2025 applied the general APR cap to all loans. The exception is a national choice.

It should be removed now, in the law itself. If it is adopted and challenged later, protection will have to be won case by case in court, clause by clause, over years, and paid for by the borrowers least able to afford it.

What protection would look like

  1. One APR cap for all loans, with no exception by size or term.
  2. Any different rule only on the basis of a published analysis.
  3. Consecutive short loans treated as a breach of the creditworthiness assessment, and systematic breaches leading to loss of the licence.
The law is meant to protect the borrower who cannot protect themselves. With the smallest loan, it should not be the one place where that protection ends.


Calculation notes: monthly cost at 52% APR is (1.52)^(1/12) − 1 = 3.55%. APR for 20% over 30 days is about 819% by the Annex I formula (about 790% on an average 30.4-day month). The three-month schedule is an equal-instalment annuity with total cost 30, which gives 14.36% per month.

The New Consumer Credit Law Exists Because Borrowers Aren't Supposed to Have to Protect Themselves
Bulgaria's draft Law on Consumer Credit passed its first reading on 23 September 2026. The debate around it is mostly about rates and registration. The actual question is simpler: can an ordinary person be expected to spot a bad loan on their own — and what happens when the law leaves gaps where they still have to?